HABARI DAILY I Kampala, Uganda I After several months of investigation, the High Court in Kampala has quashed an Auditor General’s report that had raised questions about the management of the Insurance Regulatory Authority (IRA) under its former chief executive officer, Ibrahim Kaddunabbi Lubega, faulting the manner in which the investigation was conducted and the administrative decisions that followed.
In a ruling delivered on November 9, 2026, in Miscellaneous Cause No. 198 of 2026, Justice Isaac Bonny Teko set aside the Auditor General’s report dated May 15, 2026, which had been relied upon in decisions affecting Kaddunabbi’s contract renewal.
The court’s decision followed a legal challenge by Kaddunabbi, who contested the circumstances under which the investigation was undertaken, the findings made against him and the subsequent use of the report to prevent his continued service as IRA chief executive officer.
At the centre of the dispute was whether the Permanent Secretary and Secretary to the Treasury (PSST), Ramathan Ggoobi, had acted within his legal authority when he intervened in matters concerning Kaddunabbi’s contract renewal and whether the Auditor General’s findings could lawfully be used to influence that decision without giving the former CEO an opportunity to respond.
The judgment raises important questions about the boundaries of authority within government institutions, the independence of public accountability investigations and the constitutional obligation to treat public officers fairly when administrative decisions affect their careers.
Usurping minister’s powers
One of the major grounds for the court’s decision was the role played by Ggoobi in initiating the investigation into Kaddunabbi.
The dispute started when the IRA Board declined to recommend the renewal of Kaddunabbi’s five-year contract, which ran from June 1, 2021, to May 31, 2026.
Kaddunabbi had applied for another term in May 2025, but the Board communicated its decision against his reappointment to the Minister of Finance on February 16, 2026.
Following the Board’s concerns, Ggoobi wrote to the Auditor General on March 19, 2026, requesting an investigation into allegations of financial and administrative impropriety at the regulatory authority.
However, Justice Teko found that Ggoobi had unlawfully assumed responsibilities reserved for the Minister of Finance under the Insurance Act.
The judge reasoned that the Permanent Secretary could not take over the Minister’s statutory responsibilities when the Minister was still in office.
“When the Permanent Secretary undertook a responsibility of the Minister, when the Minister was still in office, he illegally usurped the Minister’s power,” the judge ruled.
The court therefore questioned the legality of the administrative process that led to the Auditor General’s investigation, particularly because it was closely connected to the decision concerning Kaddunabbi’s contract renewal.
Why report was faulted
Justice Teko also rejected the argument that the May 15 report was automatically protected by the statutory immunity available to qualifying reports prepared by the Auditor General for Parliament.
The court found that the investigation had primarily been undertaken to address matters relating to Kaddunabbi’s contract renewal rather than to fulfil the Auditor General’s constitutional reporting responsibilities to Parliament.
Consequently, the report could not enjoy the protection claimed under Section 38 of the National Audit Act.
The court also found that the report’s subsequent use violated Article 42 of the Constitution, which guarantees fair and just administrative treatment by public authorities.
Although Kaddunabbi was given an opportunity to make representations before the IRA Board at an extraordinary meeting on May 25, 2026, the judge was not satisfied that his submissions had received genuine and open consideration.
The court emphasised that allowing an individual to speak does not automatically satisfy the constitutional right to a fair hearing if the decision-making process has effectively been predetermined.
This was particularly important because the report contained serious allegations that could damage Kaddunabbi’s professional reputation and influence decisions about his employment.
Allegations triggered investigation
The Auditor General’s May 15 report had raised several concerns about Kaddunabbi’s management of the IRA.
Among the allegations were salary increments that investigators considered irregular, excessive allowances and questionable recruitment practices.
The investigation reportedly established that Kaddunabbi’s monthly salary had increased from Sh46.34 million to Sh60.85 million between the 2021/22 and 2025/26 financial years without evidence of the required Board approval.
It also questioned full per diem payments for certain engagements that had already been sponsored, estimating an irregular expenditure of Sh57.4 million.
On recruitment, the report questioned the appointment of additional employees beyond the approved positions, estimating that the resulting salaries and benefits had cost the authority Sh647.6 million.
However, through his lawyers, Arcadia Advocates, Kaddunabbi challenged the investigation, arguing that it relied on unverified information, considered matters outside the proper investigation period and denied him an opportunity to respond before the report was finalised.
What the ruling means
The High Court ordered that the May 15 investigation report should not be used as a report to Parliament or as a basis for instituting criminal proceedings against Kaddunabbi.
However, the judgment did not establish that every financial and administrative allegation against the former IRA chief executive was false.
Neither did it overturn the IRA Board’s separate decision not to recommend renewal of his contract, since the Board was not a party to the proceedings.
The court’s decision was therefore principally about the legality of the investigation and the fairness of the administrative process through which its findings were used.
It awarded Kaddunabbi costs of the application but declined to grant damages, citing insufficient independent evidence.

